How to Start a Commonplace Book: What to Save and How to Find It Again

A notebook, a pen, and a simple topic index are enough—no decorative spreads or daily writing streak required.

A commonplace book is a notebook for keeping what you come across: a line from a novel, a useful cooking tip, an argument you want to think through, a phrase that describes something you’ve never quite had words for.

You save the material, record where it came from, and give yourself a way to find it again. Your own questions and observations can sit alongside it. The pages can be plain; the selection and the writing do the work.

Start with one entry

  1. Use a notebook you already have. Reserve its first four pages for an index.
  2. Number those pages, then begin on page 5. Keep numbering the writing pages as you reach them.
  3. Choose one thing worth keeping. Copy a short passage exactly, summarize an idea, or write down a thought of your own.
  4. Record the source. Include enough information to return to it. Label your own thinking “My note” or “My question.”
  5. Give the entry a topic word. Add a sentence about why you saved it if that would help.
  6. Put the topic and page number in the index. For example: “Friendship — 5.”

That first entry gives you something to work with. You can make the next one underneath it or on the next page; there’s no requirement to give every thought a fresh sheet.

Choose a notebook that won’t get in your way

A comfortable writing size and a binding that stays open are more useful here than special paper or an elaborate cover. You may have a source book open beside the notebook, so consider whether both will fit where you usually read.

Pre-numbered pages save a chore, but an ordinary notebook works. Add a page number whenever you begin a new page. Dates can provide context, but page numbers make better index addresses: several entries might share a date, and one subject might turn up across several months.

Choose paper you’re willing to use imperfectly. You’ll be crossing things out, adding notes in margins, and discovering that a topic you expected to love barely appears. A commonplace book needs room to change with your attention.

What to save

The useful test is: would you be glad to find this again? Save material that gives you something to think about, say, make, understand, or return to. All sample entries in this guide are invented illustrations, not quotations from real sources.

Sentences you want to return to

Lines from novels, essays, poems, talks, and interviews can all belong. Save the sentence that made you stop rather than the one you think you’re supposed to admire. A plain observation that names something you recognize has more reason to be here than a famous quotation that leaves you cold.

Copy enough surrounding language to preserve the meaning. If a sentence depends on the paragraph before it, include a brief context note rather than leaving yourself a mysterious fragment. Record the author, title, and page or location while the source is still open.

Information you’ll use again

A commonplace book can be thoroughly practical: an explanation from a workshop, a useful technique, or the detail you repeatedly have to look up. Keep the instruction together with any conditions that make it work.

Food — Dressing from cooking class: 3 tablespoons oil, 1 tablespoon vinegar, 1 teaspoon mustard.

My note: Taste it on a lettuce leaf before deciding whether to add more vinegar.

Source: Community center cooking class, April 6.

The note is useful because it adds something beyond the quantities. For a longer set of instructions, you might keep a short summary and the exact location of the full version instead of copying every step.

Things people say

A friend’s way of offering help or a coworker’s clear explanation may be worth keeping. Note who said it and the setting, provided the material isn’t private. If you’re recording someone you don’t know, leave out identifying details.

Friendship — “Would you like ideas, or would company help more?”

Source: Lena, phone conversation, April 3.

My note: Ask before launching into solutions.

When you can’t recall the wording exactly, write “As I remember it” or “Summary” and leave off quotation marks. A useful approximation can belong in the book without pretending to be a transcript.

Words and ways of saying things

Collect an unfamiliar word, an expression from another region, or a description so exact it made you laugh. For a new word, check its meaning and write a brief definition, the sentence where you encountered it, and the source.

If you want to use the word yourself, try an original sentence underneath. Keep that sentence labeled as yours. This gives you a place to practice instead of building a vocabulary list you never consult.

Ideas you disagree with

A passage can earn its place by giving you something to argue with. Save the actual claim, including qualifications that matter, then write your response separately.

Be specific about the objection. “I disagree” won’t tell you much later. “This advice assumes I control my work schedule” preserves the point you want to examine. You might also note what evidence or example would change your mind.

Keeping the source intact gives a future version of you a fair chance to reconsider both the argument and your response.

Your own unfinished thinking

An unanswered question belongs here too, as does a connection between two things you read in the same week. Label it clearly so it doesn’t become an unattributed quotation in your memory.

Change — My question: Why does a new notebook feel easier to begin than an unfinished one? What am I expecting the new paper to do?

You can leave the question open. If an answer occurs later, add it beneath the entry or write a new entry and connect the page numbers.

Lists that deserve a permanent home

Book recommendations, gift ideas, places to visit, and questions you want to explore can grow over time. Give each running list a heading and index its page. Include the detail that will make the item useful later.

Gifts — Dana mentioned wanting a bird guide she can carry on walks. Priya keeps borrowing my umbrella; ask which kind she likes.

For a book recommendation, record who suggested it and why. “For the family conversations” or “good on a long train ride” gives you more to choose from than a title alone. If a list fills its page, continue it elsewhere and leave a page reference in both places.

What to leave out

A commonplace book becomes harder to use when saving turns automatic. These are useful candidates for leaving in their original homes:

  • Everything you highlighted. Revisit the highlights and choose the few you still want outside the book. The source already holds the rest.
  • Long stretches you haven’t selected from. Find the passage at the center of your interest, then record the page range for the fuller discussion.
  • Tasks and appointments. Put anything requiring timely action into the calendar or task list you actually check. A useful idea about planning can stay; “book the appointment” needs an action system.
  • Other people’s confidences. Private messages, personal difficulties, and sensitive details don’t become collecting material because they were well phrased.
  • Material kept only to look well-read. If you can’t identify what interests you about it, leave it for now. You can return to it if that changes.

Give each entry enough context

A good entry lets you distinguish what the source said from what you thought about it. It also gives you a route back to the original. You can use a loose format rather than drawing a template on every page:

Topic
A familiar word you would think to look up, such as Work, Food, or Friendship.
Material
The exact quotation, a labeled summary, or your own idea.
Source
The details needed to locate it again.
Your note
An optional response, connection, question, or possible use.

Here is a fictional example of an entry on page 12:

Work

“Which deadline moves if this becomes the priority?”

Source: Maya, team planning meeting, April 8.

My note: Ask this before agreeing to another Friday deadline. It makes the trade-off explicit.

Keep copied words and your words separate

Use quotation marks for exact words. Label a paraphrase “Summary,” and label your response “My note.” The distinction matters most when you return months later and no longer remember making the entry.

If you shorten a quotation, use an ellipsis to show omitted words without changing the meaning. Put any explanatory words you add inside square brackets. When you want to use a quotation outside your notebook, check it against the original source rather than relying on a hurried transcription.

Write a source you can follow

For a book, record the author, title, and page number or ebook location. For an article, keep the author, title, publication, and URL. If a URL is cumbersome to copy, save it in one designated digital note and give the paper entry a matching label.

For audio or video, record the speaker, program or channel, episode title, and timestamp. “Podcast about habits” is unlikely to be enough. For your own observation, write “My observation” and add a date if the timing matters.

Add a note when it contributes something

Sometimes the reason for keeping an entry is obvious. When it isn’t, one sentence can preserve the connection: “Use this when explaining the budget,” “This contradicts the idea on page 18,” or “Ask about this at book club.”

Keep separate ideas in separate entries, even when they come from the same chapter. They can share a source note, but each should have its own topic and index reference.

Build an index you can trust

The index is a list of subjects with the pages where you’ve written about them. It doesn’t have to be alphabetized to be useful. Start by adding each new topic on the next available line of your reserved index pages.

When you save another entry on an existing topic, add its page number to that topic’s line. Leave some space after each heading for the references to grow.

  • Food — 6 (dressing), 18
  • Friendship — 7, 24 (staying in touch)
  • Gifts — 9 (running list)
  • Work — 12 (changing priorities), 27
  • Language — 16, 31

The short descriptions are optional. Add them when a bare string of numbers stops helping you distinguish one entry from another.

Use words you would actually look for

File by the idea you expect to remember. A passage about apologizing might go under Apology or Friendship, even if the author never uses either word. The source information stays with the entry; the index helps you approach it from your own interests.

Check the index before inventing a new heading. If you already use Money, decide whether a new entry belongs there before creating Finances. Similar headings can be useful when they mean different things to you, but accidental duplicates scatter your references.

Keep topics broad at first. Food is more useful than Weeknight Soups until you have enough soup to justify its own heading.

Give an entry another route in when necessary

Some material has more than one likely use. You might index an entry under both Work and Time, using the same page number. Start with one main topic and add another only when you can imagine looking for it that way.

Cross-references connect entries rather than topics. If a later passage on page 27 complicates your note on page 12, write “See also p. 27” beside the earlier entry. Add the return reference on page 27 so you can follow the connection in either direction.

Let the index grow without rebuilding the book

If a heading becomes difficult to scan, add more specific headings as you need them: Food: baking and Food: dinners, for example. The old entries can stay exactly where they are. Copy their page references under the new headings and leave a pointer beside Food.

If the reserved index pages fill, use the next blank writing page for an index continuation. Write its page number at the bottom of the original index. You haven’t run out of room; you’ve added another address.

File the entry while it’s in front of you

Add the index reference before turning to something else. This keeps you from having to reread several unfiled pages just to work out where everything belongs.

If you do fall behind, index the pages you’re using now, then work backward in manageable batches. The unfinished part doesn’t prevent the indexed part from being useful.

Try finding something before the book gets full

After you have a few entries, close the notebook and try a real retrieval. Suppose you remember saving a sentence about taking on too much work, but not who said it.

Open the index and look under Work. The note “changing priorities” points you to page 12. At the entry, you find the wording, the speaker, and your reason for saving it. You can now adapt the idea for an email without having to search through every page.

If you looked under Time first, that’s useful information about your index. Add a second reference there. If the topic was right but the page numbers were hard to distinguish, add a short description. Repair the point where you got stuck rather than redesigning the entire system.

Keep it useful without making it a daily assignment

Capture now, choose later

When your notebook isn’t nearby, jot the source and the line in a temporary note or mark the passage in a way that suits the book you’re reading. Keep these captures in one place.

When you next sit down with the commonplace book, choose what still interests you. Temporary captures are candidates, not a queue you must clear. Some passages won’t seem worth copying a few days later.

Keep the notebook where you’ll use it

Put it beside your usual reading spot or in the bag you take to a class. A notebook stored on a high shelf is easy to overlook. If you mostly collect from audio, leave it where you can review your saved timestamps.

Reread with a reason

Before a book club discussion, revisit the entries from that book. Before writing a thank-you note, check the subjects that fit the person or occasion. Use saved language as a starting point for your own wording, and keep attribution with any quotations you choose to use.

You can also browse a few recent pages whenever you add an entry. A new thought may belong beside an old one; a question may now have an answer. Add a date to later comments so you can tell which thought came first.

Continue after a gap

A month without entries doesn’t erase what you’ve collected. Start again on the next available line. Reconstructing everything you might have saved is optional, and usually less useful than recording what interests you now.

If you prefer cards or a digital notebook

The same structure works outside a bound book: material, source, your response, and a retrieval method.

For index cards, put a topic at the top and the source on every card. File them behind topic dividers. If you want to connect cards across sections, give each card a unique number so the reference still works after you move it.

For digital notes, use a consistent topic tag alongside searchable text. Search can find the words in an entry; a tag can supply an idea the passage never names. Keep each entry’s source attached rather than relying on a separate pile of links.

Choose one main home at the start. Keeping the same collection fully updated in several places adds maintenance without necessarily making it easier to use.

When the first notebook fills

Label the finished notebook with a volume number and its date range. Start the next one with an index of its own. You can carry over the topic names that proved useful without copying all the entries.

For subjects you return to across notebooks, keep a master index on a separate sheet or in a digital note. Record the volume and page together: “Work — 1:12, 1:27, 2:8.” This lets you reach across the collection without opening each notebook to check its index.

Leave the finished pages intact. Your next entry belongs in the new book; the old one remains available whenever you want the sentence, instruction, or question you saved.